From MLB Power Pros Wiki

Description

Toothache is a negative Success Mode Trait. It is acquired as a starting stat, or by using certain items (such as the chocolate sponge cake), or through random events.

Toothache is known as Tooth Decay in Success Mode 2007. You can get tooth decay by eating chocolate sponge cake.

Effect

This condition will reduce the amount of strength points gained during practice as well as in games by half.

Cure

Toothache can be cured by a visit to the hospital, or by Dr Goodjob.