Real-Life Rejects
From MLB Power Pros Wiki
(This list is for Wii players only: ps2's real-life fielder list can be found here:http://www.mlbppworld.com/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=3109&st=0&sk=t&sd=a) (And the PS2 pitcher list: http://www.mlbppworld.com/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=3134&st=0&sk=t&sd=a)
This page is going to house a team of all created players for MLBPP that were not in 2008 by default. It will include contributions by many forum members.
Many of these players were not in the big leagues in 2008 for opening day; they were either prospects or unsigned free agents, or semi-retired.
Rules for Free Agents: Any player that is not already in the MLB Power Pros game, and can/could potentially still play, is eligible for inclusion. Players that officially announced their retirement before the 2008 season (Craig Biggio, Shawn Green, etc) are not eligible.
Rules for Prospects:
- Prospect creation should focus on high-impact players from 2008 (Masterson, Maybin, Balfour, Clement, etc).
- Secondary importance is players that can be future stars (Michael Bowden, Lars Anderson).
- Since the game can only support 200 created players, and there are 30 MLB teams, we should cap creation at 5 or 6 prospects per team. Some teams maybe have deeper systems, like Boston; but let's give everyone a fair shake.
List of 2009 debuts: http://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/MLB/2009-debuts.shtml Top 25 prospects before 2008 season: http://diamondcutter.wordpress.com/top-25-prospects/
Contents |
2008-2010 High Impact Starting Pitchers
| Player | 2008 Team | Current Team | Issues? | Creator |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bartolo Colon | Red Sox | Mets | DOB Incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Roger Clemens | Retired | Retired | DOB Incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Freddy Garcia | Tigers | EDA Rhinos, Chinese Professional Baseball League | None | Alloutwar |
| Casey Fossum | Pirates/Tigers | None | DOB Incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Bruce Chen | None (Royals in 2009) | None (Released by Royals) | None | Alloutwar |
| Brett Anderson | Athletics | Dodgers | DOB Incorrect, might be overpowered, missing Durability 2 | Alloutwar |
| Trevor Cahill | Athletics | Diamondbacks | might be overpowered | philliesfan134 |
| Gio Gonzalez | Athletics | Nationals | None | Alloutwar |
| Vin Mazzaro | Athletics | Free Agent | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Bud Norris | Astros | Orioles | DOB incorrect | ZeroGibson13 |
| Brett Cecil | Blue Jays | Blue Jays | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Ricky Romero | Blue Jays | Blue Jays | might be overpowered | Alloutwar |
| Tommy Hanson | Braves | Free Agent | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Kenshin Kawakami | Chunichi Dragons | Chunichi Dragons | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Rodrigo Lopez | Braves | None | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Kris Medlen | Braves | Royals | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Charlie Morton | Braves | Pirates | None | Alloutwar |
| Jaime Garcia | Cardinals | Cardinals | None | Alloutwar |
| Jeff Samardzija | Cubs | White Sox | Vs Lefty 4 | ChiCubsFan4 |
| Jarrod Parker | Diamondbacks | Athletics | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Max Scherzer | Diamondbacks | Nationals | jag123jg | |
| Scott Elbert | Dodgers | Free Agent | Not Created Yet | Not Created Yet |
| Clayton Kershaw | Dodgers | Dodgers | None | jag123jg |
| James McDonald | Dodgers | Cubs | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Madison Bumgarner | Giants | Giants | jag123jg | |
| Doug Fister | Mariners | Nationals | DOB incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Chris Volstad | Marlins | Doosan Bears | Velocity, DOB incorrect | jacobye46 |
| Dillon Gee | Mets | Mets | None | Alloutwar |
| Jon Niese | Mets | Mets | None | Alloutwar |
| Marco Estrada | Nationals | Blue Jays | None | Alloutwar |
| Stephen Strasburg | 2009 Draftee | Nationals | DOB incorrect, pitch types | jacobye46 |
| Craig Stammen | Nationals | Nationals | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Jordan Zimmermann | Nationals | Nationals | None | Alloutwar |
| Jake Arrieta | Orioles | Cubs | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Alfredo Simon | Orioles | Tigers | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Chris Tillman | Orioles | Tigers | None | AnthonyP |
| Mat Latos | Padres | Marlins | None | Alloutwar |
| Wade LeBlanc | Padres | Free Agent | None | Alloutwar |
| J.A. Happ | Phillies | Mariners | None | Alloutwar |
| Josh Outman | Phillies | Free Agent | Stam, Ctrl both a bit low | Alloutwar |
| Jesse Chavez | Pirates | Athletics | DOB incorrect, Vs Lefty 4 | The King |
| Matt Harrison | Rangers | Rangers | None | ZeroGibson13 |
| Derek Holland | Rangers | Rangers | None | Alloutwar |
| Tommy Hunter | Rangers | Orioles | None | Alloutwar |
| Wade Davis | Rays | Royals | None | Alloutwar |
| Jeremy Hellickson | Rays | Diamondbacks | DOB incorrect | aar0nat0r |
| David Price | Rays | Tigers | None | Sparkplug15 |
| Charlie Zink | Red Sox | None | DOB incorrect, Vs. Lefty 4, Overpowered? | Dr K |
| David Pauley | Red Sox | None | ?? | |
| Jhoulys Chacin | Rockies | Rockies | Vs Lefty 4 | philliesfan134 |
| Jorge de la Rosa | Royals | Rockies | None | Alloutwar |
| Rick Porcello | Tigers | Red Sox | None | Alloutwar |
| Brian Duensing | Twins | Twins | DOB incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Daniel Hudson | White Sox | Diamondbacks | vs Lefty 4, Durability 4 | AgentP |
| Clayton Richard | White Sox | Pirates | None | Alloutwar |
| Chris Sale | 2010 Draftee | White Sox | None | BrewersFuzz |
| Ivan Nova | Yankees | Yankees | Not created yet | Not created yet |
2008-2010 High Impact Relief Pitchers
| Player | 2008 Team | Current Team | Issues? | Creator |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jose Arredondo | Angels | None | DOB incorrect, no splitter | SparkPlug15 |
| Andrew Bailey | Athletics | Yankees | DOB incorrect, Durability 2 missing | Alloutwar |
| Koji Uehara | Orioles 2009 signee, Japan | Red Sox | AgentP | |
| Ryan Webb | Athletics | Orioles | DOB incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Brad Ziegler | Athletics | Diamondbacks | Vs Lefty 4 | AgentP |
| Craig Kimbrel | 2009 draftee | Braves | jag123jg | |
| Chris Perez | Cardinals | Free Agent | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Sergio Romo | Giants | Giants | None | Alloutwar |
| Luke Gregerson | Padres | Astros | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Neftali Feliz | Rangers | Rangers | philliesfan134 | |
| [Grant Balfour] | Rays | Rays | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Justin Masterson | Red Sox | Red Sox | Vs Lefty 4, low stamina | jacobye46 |
| Daniel Bard | Red Sox | Free Agent | Overpowered | Alloutwar |
| Aroldis Chapman | Cuban signee 2010 | Reds | ? | jag123jg |
| Alfredo Aceves | Yankees | Yankees | DOB incorrect, Vs Lefty 4 | radclayson |
| Phil Coke | Yankees | Free Agent | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| David Robertson | Yankees | White Sox | DOB incorrect | radclayson |
2008-2010 High Impact Infielders
| Player | 2008 Team | Current Team | Issues? | Creator |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pokey Reese | Nationals | None | Alloutwar | |
| Cliff Pennington | Athletics | Diamondbacks | None | DishNet34 |
| Chris Johnson | Astros | Braves | None | Alloutwar |
| Lance Niekro | Astros | None | Pitching abilities, overpowered? | |
| Freddie Freeman | Braves | Braves | throwing 4? | philliesfan134 |
| Alcides Escobar | Brewers | Royals | None | Alloutwar |
| Russell Branyan | Brewers | None | Probably overpowered | Alloutwar |
| Darwin Barney | Cubs | Dodgers | AgentP | |
| Starlin Castro | Cubs | Cubs | DOB incorrect, overpowered? | Zumikaku |
| Casey McGehee | Cubs | Mariners | None | Alloutwar |
| Brett Wallace | Cardinals | Padres | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Andres Blanco | Cubs | Phillies | DOB incorrect | Zumikaku |
| Josh Donaldson | Cubs | Blue Jays | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Pablo Sandoval | Giants | Red Sox | None | Alloutwar |
| Bryan Lahair | Mariners | Free Agent | DOB incorrect | jacobye46 |
| Luis Valbuena | Mariners | Cubs | AgentP | |
| Dallas McPherson | Marlins | None | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Gaby Sanchez | Marlins | Free Agent | Lots of blues, overpowered? | dishnet34 |
| Ike Davis | 2008 draftee | Athletics | DOB incorrect, Lots of blues, overpowered? | jacobye46 |
| Lucas Duda | Mets | Mets | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Daniel Murphy | Mets | Mets | Alloutwar | |
| Ruben Tejada | Mets | Mets | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Ian Desmond | Nationals | Nationals | None | Alloutwar |
| Mike Costanzo | Orioles | Free Agent | DOB incorrect, overpowered? | DrMario |
| Neil Walker | Pirates | Pirates | Alloutwar | |
| Everth Cabrera | Rockies | Free Agent | None | Zumikaku |
| David Freese | Padres | Angels | AgentP | |
| Chase Headley | Padres | Yankees | Alloutwar | |
| Pedro Alvarez | Pirates | Pirates | Power very high | mikeypags28 |
| Chris Davis | Rangers | Orioles | DOB incorrect | jacobye46 |
| Elvis Andrus | Rangers | Rangers | None | Alloutwar |
| Mitch Moreland | Rangers | Rangers | AgentP | |
| Justin Smoak | Rangers | Blue Jays | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Reid Brignac | Rays | Marlins | DOB incorrect | AgentP |
| Todd Frazier | Reds | Reds | Ham Bone | |
| Paul Janish | Reds | Free Agent | MPH should be higher as a pitcher | Alloutwar |
| Lars Anderson | Red Sox | Free Agent | DOB incorrect, overpowered | Dr K |
| Chris Carter | Red Sox | Free Agent | DOB incorrect, overpowered? | dishnet34 |
| Mike Aviles | Royals | Indians | DOB incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Scott Sizemore | Tigers | Marlins | DOB incorrect | dishnet34 |
| Garrett Jones | Twins | Marlins | DOB incorrect | jacobye46 |
| Trevor Plouffe | Twins | Twins | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Gordon Beckham | White Sox | Free Agent | jacobye46 | |
| Chris Getz | White Sox | None | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Ramiro Pena | Yankees | Braves | radclayson | |
| Nick Green | Yankees | Free Agent | 3rd position is LF instead of 3B | Alloutwar |
2008-2010 High Impact Outfielders
| Player | 2008 Team | Current Team | Issues? | Creator |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barry Bonds | Free Agent | Retired | DOB incorrect, overpowered? | Alloutwar |
| Bernie Williams | Free Agent | Retired | Overpowered | Alloutwar |
| Peter Bourjous | Angels | Cardinals | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Mark Trumbo | Angels | Diamondbacks | None | dishnet34 |
| Carlos Gonzalez | Athletics | Rockies | Underpowered? | Alloutwar |
| Travis Snider | Blue Jays | Pirates | DOB incorrect | jacobye46 |
| Michael Brantley | Brewers | Indians | dishnet34 | |
| Jason Heyward | Braves | Cardinals | philliesfan134 | |
| Jordan Schafer | Braves | Twins | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Matt LaPorta | Brewers | None | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Laynce Nix | Brewers | Retired | None | Zumikaku |
| Jon Jay | Cardinals | Cardinals | DOB incorrect [birth year off by 1] | dishnet34 |
| Colby Rasmus | Cardinals | Free Agent | Alloutwar | |
| Tyler Colvin | Cubs | Free Agent | ChiCubsFan4 | |
| Sam Fuld | Cubs | Athletics | No pitching abilities | aar0nat0r |
| Gerardo Parra | Diamondbacks | Brewers | DOB incorrect, name misspelled | jacobye46 |
| Michael Saunders | Mariners | Blue Jays | Dishnet34 | |
| Cameron Maybin | Marlins | Padres | jacobye46 | |
| Chris Coghlan | Marlins | Marlins | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Logan Morrison | Marlins | Mariners | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Marlins | Marlins | aar0nat0r | |
| Trot Nixon | Mets | Retired | DOB incorrect, position LF | Dr K |
| Roger Bernadina | Nationals | Rockies | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Nolan Reimold | Orioles | Free Agent | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Domonic Brown | Phillies | Phillies | AgentP | |
| Andrew McCutchen | Pirates | Pirates | jacobye46 | |
| Jose Tabata | Pirates | Pirates | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Will Venable | Padres | Padres | Alloutwar | |
| Julio Borbon | Rangers | Rangers | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Nelson Cruz | Rangers | Mariners | jag123jg | |
| Craig Gentry | Rangers | Athletics | Text16 | |
| John Mayberry | Rangers | Mets | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Matt Joyce | Rays | Angels | dishnet34 | |
| Desmond Jennings | Rays | Rays | DOB incorrect | aar0nat0r |
| Jay Bruce | Reds | Reds | DOB incorrect | jacobye46 |
| Darnell McDonald | Reds | Retired | Alloutwar | |
| Drew Stubbs | Reds | Rockies | AgentP | |
| Johnathan Van Every | Red Sox | Appearance all off - big anime eyes, long hair, all wrong | cooldude1045 | |
| Daniel Nava | Red Sox | Red Sox | DOB incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Josh Reddick | Red Sox | Athletics | aar0nat0r | |
| Dexter Fowler | Rockies | Astros | DOB incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Eric Young Jr | Rockies | Free Agent | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Brennan Boesch | Tigers | Reds | Not created yet | Not created yet |
| Ben Revere | Twins | Phillies | dishnet34 | |
| Dayan Viciedo | White Sox | White Sox | philliesfan134 | |
| Brett Gardner | Yankees | Yankees | Alloutwar | |
| Austin Jackson | Yankees | Tigers | DOB incorrect | dishnet34 |
2008-2010 High Impact Catchers
| Player | 2008 Team | Current Team | Issues? | Creator |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Doug Mirabelli | Free Agent | Retired | DOB incorrect | Dr K |
| Landon Powell | Athletics | Retired | None | Alloutwar |
| JP Arencibia | Blue Jays | Free Agent | Alloutwar | |
| Jonathan Lucroy | Brewers | Brewers | Alloutwar | |
| Koyie Hill | Cubs | Free Agent | DOB incorrect | ChiCubsFan4 |
| Carlos Santana | Dodgers | Indians | Catcher only | redsfan |
| Buster Posey | Giants | Giants | redsfan | |
| John Baker | Marlins | Free Agent | DOB incorrect | Alloutwar |
| Josh Thole | Mets | Blue Jays | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Matt Wieters | Orioles | Orioles | overpowered? | Alloutwar |
| Nick Hundley | Padres | Free Agent | None | Alloutwar |
| Jose Lobaton | Padres | Nationals | aar0nat0r | |
| Taylor Teagarden | Rangers | Free Agent | Not yet created | Not yet created |
| John Jaso | Rays | Athletics | AgentP | |
| Alex Avila | Tigers | Tigers | overpowered? | dishnet34, detroittigers15 |
| Francisco Cervelli | Yankees | Pirates | DOB incorrect | radclayson |
Later-debut players (2011-2015)
| Player | Year drafted/signed | MLB debut | Current Team | Issues? | Creator |
| Drew Butera | 2005 draftee, Mets | 2010 Twins | Angels | Prediction | |
| Kole Calhoun | 2010 draftee, Angels | 2012 Angels | Angels | aar0nat0r | |
| Andrew Heaney | 2012 draftee, Marlins | 2014 Marlins | Angels | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Dan Robertson | 2008 draftee, Padres | 2014 Rangers | Angels | AgentP | |
| Josh Rutledge | 2010 draftee, Rockies | 2010 Rockies | Angels | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Tyler Skaggs | 2009 draftee, Angels | 2012 Angels | Angels | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Mike Trout | 2009 draftee, Angels | 2011 Angels | Angels | DOB incorrect, Power too high | Text16 |
| Sonny Gray | 2011 draftee, Athletics | 2013 Athletics | Athletics | Vs Lefty 4 | philliesfan34 |
| AJ Griffin | 2010 draftee, Athletics | 2012 Athletics | Athletics | philliesfan134 | |
| Jose Altuve | 2007 Venezuelan signee, Astros | 2011 Astros | Astros | The King | |
| Matt Dominguez | 2009 draftee, Marlins | 2011 Marlins | Astros | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Lucas Harrell | 2004 draftee, White Sox | 2010 White Sox | Astros | AgentP | |
| LJ Hoes | 2008 draftee, Orioles | 2012 Orioles | Astros | philliesfan134 | |
| Brett Oberholtzer | 2008 draftee, Braves | 2013 Astros | Astros | philliesfan134 | |
| Jon Singleton | 2009 draftee, Philllies | 2014 Astros | Astros | LetsGoMets77 | |
| George Springer | 2011 draftee, Astros | 2014 Astros | Astros | philliesfan134 | |
| Jonathan Villar | 2008 Dominican signee, Phillies | 2013 Astros | Astros | philliesfan134 | |
| Shelby Miller | 2009 draftee, Cardinals | 2012 Cardinals | Braves | philliesfan134 | |
| Andrelton Simmons | 2010 draftee, Braves | 2012 Braves | Braves | DOB incorrect | jag123jg |
| Scooter Gennett | 2009 draftee, Brewers | 2013 Brewers | Brewers | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Wily Peralta | 2006 Dominican signee, Brewers | 2012 Brewers | Brewers | overpowered? | BrewersFuzz |
| Jean Segura | 2007 Dominican signee, Angels | 2012 Angels | Brewers | Overpowered? | BrewersFuzz |
| Seth Maness | 2011 draftee, Cardinals | 2013 Cardinals | Cardinals | philliesfan134 | |
| Trevor Rosenthal | 2009 draftee, Cardinals | 2012 Cardinals | Cardinals | philliesfan134 | |
| Oscar Tavares | 2008 Dominican signee, Cardinals | 2014 Cardinals | Deceased | overpowered? | Mr Singles |
| Javier Baez | 2011 draftee, Cubs | 2014 Cubs | Cubs | DOB Incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Welington Castillo | 2004 Dominican signee, Cubs | 2012 Cubs | Cubs | overpowered? | MrLiamcar |
| Junior Lake | 2007 Dominican signee, Cubs | 2013 Cubs | Cubs | philliesfan134 | |
| Anthony Rizzo | 2007 draftee, Red Sox | 2011 Padres | Cubs | AgentP | |
| Jorge Soler | 2011 Cuban signee, Cubs | 2014 Cubs | Cubs | philliesfan134 | |
| Jacob Turner | 2009 draftee, Tigers | 2011 Marlins | Cubs | Vs Lefty 4 | dishnet34 |
| Paul Goldschmidt | 2009 draftee, Diamondbacks | 2011 Diamondbacks | Diamondbacks | jag123jg | |
| Yasmani Tomas | 2014 Cuban signee, Diamondbacks | Not Yet Debuted | Diamondbacks | aar0nat0r | |
| Yasiel Puig | 2012 Cuban signee, Dodgers | 2013 Dodgers | Dodgers | BrewersFuzz | |
| Brandon Belt | 2009 draftee, Giants | 2011 Giants | Giants | overpowered? | Ham Bone |
| Dan Runzler | 2007 draftee, Giants | 2009 Giants | Giants | AgentP | |
| Hunter Strickland | 2007 draftee, Red Sox | 2014 Giants | Giants | mph a bit low | LetsGoMets77 |
| Trevor Bauer | 2011 draftee, Diamondbacks | 2012 Diamondbacks | Indians | DOB incorrect, Vs Lefty 4 | philliesfan134 |
| Jason Kipnis | 2009 draftee, Indians | 2011 Indians | Indians | Name is misspelled | Text16 |
| Corey Kluber | 2007 draftee, Padres | 2011 Indians | Indians | vs Lefty 4 | jag123jg |
| Dustin Ackley | 2009 draftee, Mariners | 2011 Mariners | Mariners | rybo24 | |
| Hisashi Iwakuma | 2011 Japanese signee, Mariners | 2012 Mariners | Mariners | missing splitter/shutto, top spd, vs Lefty 4 | rybo24 |
| Jesus Montero | 2008 Venezuelan signee, Yankees | 2011 Yankees | Mariners | overpowered? | Ham Bone |
| Taijuan Walker | 2010 draftee, Mariners | 2013 Mariners | Mariners | Vs Lefty 4 | Mr Singles |
| Taijuan Walker alt | 2010 draftee, Mariners | 2013 Mariners | Mariners | overpowered? | philliesfan134 |
| Mike Zunino | 2012 draftee, Mariners | 2013 Mariners | Mariners | overpowered? | rybo24 |
| Carter Capps | 2011 draftee, Mariners | 2012 Mariners | Marlins | DOB incorrect, Vs Left 4 | philliesfan134 |
| Jarred Cosart | 2008 draftee, Phillies | 2013 Astros | Marlins | philliesfan134 | |
| Jose Fernandez | 2011 draftee, Marlins | 2013 Marlins | Marlins | Vs Lefty 4 | philliesfan134 |
| Dee Gordon | 2008 draftee, Dodgers | 2011 Dodgers | Marlins | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Adeiny Hechavarria | 2010 Cuban signee, Blue Jays | 2012 Blue Jays | Marlins | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Andre Rienzo | 2006 Brazilian signee, White Sox | 2013 White Sox | Marlins | vs Lefty 4 | LetsGoMets77 |
| Christian Yelich | 2010 draftee, Marlins | 2013 Marlins | Marlins | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Dario Alvarez | 2007 Dominican signee, Phillies | 2014 Mets | Mets | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Vic Black | 2009 draftee, Pirates | 2013 Pirates | Mets | Vs Lefty 4 | LetsGoMets77 |
| Travis D'Arnaud | 2007 draftee, Phillies | 2013 Mets | Mets | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Jacob DeGrom | 2010 draftee, Mets | 2014 Mets | Mets | Vs Lefty 4 | jag123jg |
| Josh Edgin | 2010 draftee, Mets | 2012 Mets | Mets | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Matt Harvey | 2010 draftee, Mets | 2012 Mets | Mets | Vs Lefty 4 | Acemaker55 |
| Juan Lagares | 2006 Dominican signee, Mets | 2013 Mets | Mets | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Jenrry Mejia | 2007 Dominican signee, Mets | 2010 Mets | Mets | DOB incorrect | jag123jg |
| Rafael Montero | 2011 Dominican signee, Mets | 2014 Mets | Mets | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Kirk Nieuwenhuis | 2008 draftee, Mets | 2012 Mets | Mets | Name misspelled | AgentP |
| Cesar Puello | 2007 Dominican signee, Mets | None yet | Mets | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Zack Wheeler | 2009 draftee, Giants | 2012 Mets | Mets | jag123jg | |
| Bryce Harper | 2010 draftee, Nationals | 2012 Nationals | Nationals | DOB incorrect | AgentP |
| Anthony Rendon | 2011 draftee, Nationas | 2013 Nationals | Nationals | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Manny Machado | 2010 draftee, Orioles | 2012 Orioles | Orioles | DOB incorrect | AgentP |
| Alexi Amarista | 2007 Venezuelan signee, Angels | 2011 Angels | Padres | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Odrisamer Despaigne | 2014 Cuban signee, Padres | 2014 Padres | Padres | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Jedd Gyorko | 2010 draftee, Padres | 2013 Padres | Padres | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Casey Kelly | 2008 draftee, Red Sox | 2012 Padres | Padres | DOB incorrect, Vs Lefty 4 | LetsGoMets77 |
| Brandon Maurer | 2008 draftee, Mariners | 2013 Mariners | Padres | Vs Lefty 4, top spd, high stam | philliesfan134 |
| Will Middlebrooks | 2007 draftee, Red Sox | 2012 Red Sox | Padres | overpowered? | AnthonyP |
| Wil Myers | 2009 draftee, Royals | 2013 Rays | Padres | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Derek Norris | 2007 draftee, Nationals | 2012 Athletics | Padres | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Kevin Quackenbush | 2011 draftee, Padres | 2014 Padres | Padres | LetsGoMets77 | |
| Phillippe Aumont | 2007 draftee, Mariners | 2012 Phillies | Phillies | DOB incorrect, Vs Lefty 4 | LetsGoMets77 |
| Ken Giles | 2011 draftee, Phillies | 2014 Phillies | Phillies | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Gerritt Cole | 2011 draftee, Pirates | 2013 Pirates | Pirates | Vs Lefty 4 | philliesfan134 |
| Starling Marte | 2007 Dominican signee, Pirates | 2012 Pirates | Pirates | aar0nat0r | |
| Alex Cobb | 2006 draftee, Rays | 2011 Rays | Rays | DOB incorrect, Vs Lefty 4 | aar0nat0r |
| Nick Franklin | 2009 draftee, Mariners | 2013 Mariners | Rays | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Matt Moore | 2007 draftee, Rays | 2011 Rays | Rays | philliesfan134 | |
| Drew Smyly | 2010 draftee, Tigers | 2012 Tigers | Rays | DOB incorrect | dishnet34 |
| Brock Holt | 2009 draftee, Pirates | 2012 Pirates | Red Sox | AgentP | |
| Billy Hamilton | 2009 draftee, Reds | 2013 Reds | Reds | DOB incorrect | aar0nat0r |
| Nolan Arenado | 2009 draftee, Rockies | 2013 Rockies | Rockies | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Tim Collins | 2007 amateur signee, Royals | 2011 Royals | Royals | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Greg Holland | 2007 draftee, Royals | 2010 Royals | Royals | AgentP | |
| Mike Moustakas | 2007 draftee, Royals | 2011 Royals | Royals | DOB incorrect | Text16 |
| Salvador Perez | 2006 Venezuelan signee, Royals | 2011 Royals | Royals | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Nick Castellanos | 2010 draftee, Tigers | 2013 Tigers | Tigers | DOB incorrect | dishnet34 |
| Yoenis Cespedes | 2012 Cuban signee, Athletics | 2012 Athletics | Tigers | AgentP | |
| Anthony Gose | 2008 draftee, Astros | 2012 Blue Jays | Tigers | Prediction | |
| Jose Iglesias | 2009 Cuban signee, Red Sox | 2011 Red Sox | Tigers | DOB incorrect | dishnet34 |
| Ian Krol | 2009 draftee, Athletics | 2013 Nationals | Tigers | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Aaron Hicks | 2008 draftee, Twins | 2013 Twins | Twins | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Josmil Pinto | 2006 Venezuelan signee, Twins | 2013 Twins | Twins | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets |
| Danny Santana | 2007 Dominican signee, Twins | 2014 Twins | Twins | DOB incorrect | BrewersFuxx |
| Chris Archer | 2006 draftee, Indians | 2012 Rays | Rays | DOB incorrect (off by 5 yrs) | aar0nat0r |
| Jose Abreu | 2013 Cuban signee, White Sox | 2014 White Sox | White Sox | jag12jg | |
| Tony Campana | 2008 draftee, Cubs | 2011 Cubs | White Sox | AgentP | |
| Jose Quintana | 2006 Colombian signee, Mets | 2012 White Sox | White Sox | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Dellin Betances | 2006 draftee, Yankees | 2011 Yankees | Yankees | jag123jg | |
| Nate Eovaldi | 2008 draftee, Dodgers | 2011 Dodgers | Yankees | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Didi Gregorious | 2007 Dutch signee, Reds | 2012 Reds | Yankees | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Michael Pineda | 2005 Dominican signee, Mariners | 2011 Mariners | Yankees | DOB incorrect, Vs Lefty 4 | dishnet34 |
| Jose Pirela | 2006 Venezuelan signee, Yankees | 2014 Yankees | Yankees | DOB incorrect | LetsGoMets77 |
| Masahiro Tanaka | 2014 Japanese signee, Yankees | 2014 Yankees | Yankees | DOB incorrect | philliesfan134 |
| Jung-Ho Kang | None | Not Yet Debuted | Free Agent | LetsGoMets77 |
Alternate/Older versions of players created
- David Freese |Padres |Angels|Gold Glover, low Arm|Text16|-
- Mike Trout (Angels) |E Contact
- Josh Reddick (Athletics)
- |Craig Kimbrel |2009 draftee|Braves|Stamina too high|mikeypags28|-
- Starlin Castro (Cubs) |A Contact |BrewersFuzz
- Clayton Kershaw (Dodgers)
- Clayton Kershaw (AOW early)
- Madison Bumgarner |Giants|Giants|DOB incorrect, skin tone incorrect|Ham Bone|-
- Buster Posey (Giants) |PWR and abilities too high |Text16
- Corey Kluber |AgentP original
- Max Scherzer |Diamondbacks|Free Agent|Stamina low|Alloutwar|-
- Stephen Strasburg (Nationals)
- David Price |2007 draftee, Rays |Tigers | |jag123jg |-
