CY Young 08 winners

ChiCubsFan4 · **Posted:** Wed Sep 17, 2008 8:51 pm

stevenjackson39 wrote:

BBiship2 wrote:

NL - Tim Lincecum

AL - Cliff Lee

That's exactly my pick.

Same here. CLEARLY.

mike94100 · **Posted:** Wed Sep 17, 2008 8:54 pm

ChiCubsFan4 wrote:

stevenjackson39 wrote:

BBiship2 wrote:

NL - Tim Lincecum

AL - Cliff Lee

That's exactly my pick.

Same here. CLEARLY.

they are the obvious winners.

DrMario · **Posted:** Wed Sep 17, 2008 8:56 pm

Sparkplug15 wrote:

Cliff Lee is the one I want to see in the AL, just because he was playing in the AAA last year....
And I think that Tim Lincecum deserves it in the NL.....he has a great era..and he is very close to Webb in wins.....and since Webb has been "off" the last few games....Tim could win it...

In the AL you can't leave out Dice-K, he should be in that race.

Sparkplug15 · **Posted:** Wed Sep 17, 2008 9:00 pm

[quote="DrMario"]
In the AL you can't leave out Dice-K, he should be in that race.
[/quote

Well I don't think that is going to happen....(sadly...he is one of my favorite players)
Cliff Lee has 5 more wins...
14 more strikeouts...
And a lower era...

But you never know.....

cownip · **Posted:** Wed Sep 17, 2008 10:12 pm

I don't think there's any competition in the AL, Dice-K has a lower win percentage, much less innings, less Ks, much less wins, much high ERA (not that it's high or anything, Cliff Lee is just that good. I like Cliff Lee, the Indian's have at least 1 thing to keep there hopes alive).

DrMario · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 7:32 am

Dice-K still has like 2 starts left, you never know, he's 8-0 on the road!

Remember last year? Josh Beckett had a great season, probably a bit better than C.C but C.C still won CY Young award.

Me_and_Lucy · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 10:39 am

CC had more SO, made the diff. Dice-K is clearly out. The max he can do is finish 19-2? But Cliff has a better ERA and SO.

stevenjackson39 · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 4:23 pm

Cliff has been the only bright spot for his team, though.
without lee, the indians would be over 25 games under .500.

cownip · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 4:29 pm

That's not true, the number 5 starter to replace him would have at least 1 win. But he has made a tremendous effect. While I don't think he's that ood of a pitcher and is just having an incredible year, I think he is an exellent pitcher and won't simply go away next year.

stevenjackson39 · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 4:49 pm

can't believe i haven't edited him yet...

congrats on 400 (quality :mrgreen:

)posts cownip

DrMario · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 7:28 pm

Me_and_Lucy wrote:

CC had more SO, made the diff. Dice-K is clearly out. The max he can do is finish 19-2? But Cliff has a better ERA and SO.

All it takes is one bad start for Lee.

Chief · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 10:58 pm

cownip wrote:

That's not true, the number 5 starter to replace him would have at least 1 win. But he has made a tremendous effect. While I don't think he's that ood of a pitcher and is just having an incredible year, I think he is an exellent pitcher and won't simply go away next year.

I think he might start out the season, sadly, like C.C. did this year, BAD. Then he will play like there is a chip on his shoulder and pitch great ball.

Me_and_Lucy · **Posted:** Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:26 pm

DrMario wrote:

Me_and_Lucy wrote:

CC had more SO, made the diff. Dice-K is clearly out. The max he can do is finish 19-2? But Cliff has a better ERA and SO.

All it takes is one bad start for Lee.

Erm....22-3? Dice-K 19-2 (Max) The win% is clearly in favor to Lee. But will he get a unanimous discision?

Schwammy1121 · **Posted:** Fri Sep 19, 2008 9:34 am

Lincecum and Lee
its just too bad that lincecum didn't get to pitch the all-star game

ChiCubsFan4 · **Posted:** Fri Sep 19, 2008 10:15 am

Schwammy1121 wrote:

Lincecum and Lee
its just too bad that lincecum didn't get to pitch the all-star game

I know. Wasn't he supposed to be there?

Power Pros Forum

Forum rules

CY Young 08 winners

Who is online