Power Pros Forum

QB

32. Johnny Manziel
31. Mariota
30. Winston
29. EJ Manuel
28. Case Keenum
27. Geno Smith
26. Blake Bortles
25. Derek Carr
24. Nick Foles
23. RG3
22. Mark Sanchez
21. Teddy Bridgewater
20. Carson Palmer
19. Jay Cutler
18. Andy Dalton
17. Colin Kaepernick
16. Eli Manning
15. Cam Newton
14. Alex Smith
13. Ryan Tannehill
12. Matthew Stafford
11. Philip Rivers
10. Joe Flacco
9. Ben Roethlisberger
8. Matt Ryan
7. Tony Romo
6. Russell Wilson
5. Peyton Manning
4. Drew Brees
3. Andrew Luck
2. Tom Brady
1. Aaron Rodgers

Right now I have my QBs done. If you want to post what you think it would okay with me.

Looks good, except I think you have Wilson and Smith too high, and Big Ben too low.

I also think you have Winston and Mariota too low, but I understand that since they're rookies, some people don't like to rank them.

RB

32. Doug Martin
31. Chris Ivory
30. LeGarrette Blount
29. Isaiah Crowell
28. Joseph Randle
27. Rashad Jennings
26. C.J. Spiller
25. T.J. Yeldon
24. Andre Ellington
23. Joique Bell
22. Latavius Murray
21. Tevin Coleman
20. Todd Gurley
19. Melvin Gordon
18. Frank Gore
17. Jonathan Stewart
16. Justin Forsett
15. Lamar Miller
14. Carlos Hyde
13. Mark Ingram
12. Alfred Morris
11. Jeremy Hill
10. C.J. Anderson
9. Matt Forte
8. Arian Foster
7. DeMarco Murray
6. LeSean McCoy
5. Eddie Lacy
4. Adrian Peterson
3. Le'Veon Bell
2. Jamaal Charles
1. Marshawn Lynch

Why is Bell number 3? He has a 2 game suspension to start with. Also same with Brady at number 2.

they are ranked how i think they'll impact the team

My opinion on QBs:

1. Winston
2. 31 tied for 2nd

#NoleNation
#ItsABucsLife

Where is Darrren McFadden?

i only put the starters in the rankings

probably re-habbing another injury

Oh wait, he's not with Oakland anymore.

Also, RM, you got me wanting to do my own one of these now

Edit: Eli should be top 15 to me, and no way RG3 and Sanchez are better than my man Derek Carr. Also, you underrated Palmer

Aaron Rodgers <3

Eli throw too many picks.
Palmer is coming back from an injury.
Derek Carr doesn't have anyone to throw too, so he won't make an impact.

Eli had a very good season last year. It's clear that he's not the problem in NY. Also, Peyton threw more picks than Eli last year so...
Palmer will still be good. He'll pick up right where he left off last season.
Dude watch Carr throw bombs to Amari next season

I gotta agree that Big Ben is too low in the QB ranks.

Side note: remember when Doug Martin was incredible? Yeah, a while ago. It's ironic, as a Giants fan, how the Bucs traded for that #31 pick to grab Martin and then at #32 we wound up taking Wilson... two late first rounder who never turned into what they were supposed to.

Young QB drafted in 1st round plays 1 game and a quarter of bad football = worst qb in the league

No

everything else seems fine i guess but mariota and winston get ranked too low cuz theyre rookies but id rather have mariota my day1 starter than geno

that's not really the reason i put manziel last. I made this list based off of possible impact for the team. here are the reason he is rated so low:

1) In college we ALL saw he would just throw the ball deep and be lucky that his team had good WRs like Mike Evans
2) He tries to scramble too much and it won't work at the NFL level
2.5) If he tries to scramble he will get hurt and he will be RG3 Jr. which I believe will happen
3) If you play 5 quarters you better throw at least 1 touchdown
4) He completed just over 50% of his passes which is terrible
5) He averaged only 5 YARDS per pass

Also Manziel has worked mostly with the 2nd string offense so far and he has done terrible