Power Pros Forum

OK, so, as you know, I was working on a project to make everybody (well, almost everybody) that was in the 2011 MLB All-Star game that wasn't in MLBPP 08 already. I've completed the AL roster, (save for Chris Perez, Ricky Romero, and Jordan Walden, since they couldn't fit) and almost have the NL roster done (except for editing somebody to be Jonny Venters).

My question is, when I make the arrange team of all the players in the roster that are in the game/made in Success Mode/edited, which team should I pick to be the starter (other than the default AL and NL All-Star teams) and, most importantly, who do I put where (example: do I put Alexi Ogando in the AAA section or the MLB section?)

Please help, because I really have no idea on what to do.

Why can't you use the NL and AL All-Stars as the base team? And shouldn't you put everybody in MLB so you can use them in the game?

1. Because then it'll show the team they were playing on in 08, which really won't help much, like, Roy Halladay playing for the NL in a Blue Jays uniform.
2. I can't put everyobdy in MLB, because of the 25 player limit in MLB. If I do play with one of the teams though, I will use 40-man roster, so I can use the players I put in AAA also.
3. Because I like the jerseys the players wore for the HRD.

Make an edited team.

That's what I'm trying to do, AgentP.

Note that by that, I meant use an AL and NL team (i.e. Red Sox and Cubs), then go to "EDIT TEAM" in the top left corner.

I know, that's what I intend to do. But I'm wondering which team(s) I should use to make the rosters with.

Well, how many pitchers and how many hitters are on each team? For my Arrange Mode Project, I used 14 hitters and 11 pitchers, so if you're going to do that, then I'd use the White Sox and Pirates.

Well, here's my rosters so far (note that most of the players I will edit sooner or later to be like their 2011 selves):

AL (MLB)
Pitchers:
Beckett
Lester
Shields
Hernandez
Verlander
Weaver
C.J. Wilson (Edited to be a starter)
Rivera
League
Valverde
Sabathia

Fielders:
Avila
Youkilis
Gonzalez
Ortiz
A. Cabrera
Cano
Kendrick
M. Cabrera
Beltre
Bautista
Peralta
Granderson
Hamilton
Cuddyer

AAA:
Pitchers:
Price (Success)
Robertson (Success)
Pineda (Success)
Ogando (Edited)
Crow (Edited)
G. Gonzalez (Success)

Fielders:
Weiters (Success)
Martin
Konerko
A-Rod
Jeter
Young
Quentin
Ellsbury
Joyce (Success)

NL
MLB:
Pitchers:
Cain
Bell
Correia
Lee (Edited)
Halladay
Hamels
Wilson
Hanrahan
Lincecum

Fielders:
Molina
McCann
Berkman
Votto
Fielder
Phillips
Weeks
Jones
Rolen
Tulowitski
Castro (Success)
Holliday
Braun
Beltran
Ethier
Kemp

AAA:
Pitchers:
Kershaw (Success)
Cli[ppard (edited)
Kimbrel (Edited)
Jurrjens (Edited)
Venters (Edited)

Fielders:
Montero
Sanchez (Success)
Polanco
Sandoval (Success)
Reyes
McCutchen (Success)
Victorino
Pence
Upton
Bruce (Success)

So, yeah, I need to move a few players around, but who should I move where?

Move Pence to the Majors. He gunned down Robby Cano in that game, remember?

I'd put Correia in AAA and Kershaw in MLB. Kershaw actually pitched in the game.