Power Pros Forum

I know its Christmas, but I've had this idea in my head for a while. Today's poll question is; Who do you think will win the NFL comeback player of the year award? Adrian Peterson? Peyton Manning? Both? Neither? Please vote!

This is a really tough choice, I think they both deserve it, but in the history of the award, there was only one year where 2 players were selected. But, I think AP will win, because he's having an amazing season. Not saying Peyton Manning isn't, but he isn't on the verge of breaking the passing yards record, like AP is with the rushing yards record. But still, its 207 yards to go to break the record. He shredded the Packers last time though, so we'll see.

I'm gonna say AP, but it's definitely a tough decision.

Tom Brady

Neither

I'd say AP, but it's very, very, close! AP is about to break the rushing mark but Peyton is gonna lead his team into the late playoffs if not winning the SB.

Peyton.

I would like to point out Thomas Davis as another candidate. He's a LB for the Panthers.

Peyton Manning, but you really can't go wrong.

Neck surgery, though. Who knew he could come back like this?

Yeah, but Peterson tore his ACL. Nobody thought he would come back as good as he was, let alone BETTER.

I find it hard to believe that anyone can think that someone other than Peyton Manning would win, really.

I think they both have such a strong case that they would have to both win it.

I personally think it should be Peyton as Comeback POTY and Adrian Peterson for MVP, but in reality I think it'll be the other way around.