Power Pros Forum

Hey guys who do you think is gonna be rookie of the year for the NL. I am a Reds fan, but I really do think it is gonna be Frazier.

You put Cozart but not Lance Lynn or Aoki?

Look I put other...

I did this based on another website...

Miley and Harper both made the all-star game but I'd go with Miley.

miley and frazier are going to be 1 and 2 no matter what

This one's another tough one, though I'll go Frazier. Miley is definitely right up there, with Harper right behind.

It will be between Miley and Frazier. Miley to win ROTY for the NL but I expect it to be closer than the AL.

Other --> Brandon Barnes

It appears that two pitchers (Miley and Lynn) and about four batters (Harper/Rosario/Frazier/Aoki) will pick up multiple votes. There really isn't a clear cut offensive player. Miley seems to be gaining steam among writers, but it is so close that a strong finish for Harper, Frazier or even Rosario could result in one of those guys winning.

I say Harper.

??? I still say that people have him way better than he really is. I say he sucks. And my second favorite team is the Nats so I still say he sucks. Most Nats people think he is a God.

Frazier stats:
GP AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS WAR
122 409 54 114 26 6 18 64 35 100 3 2 .279 .338 .504 .842 1.9
Miley Stats: Season
W L SV G GS IP
16 10 0 30 27 183.0
Harper stats:
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA
131 568 507 92 132 23 8 19 53 16 6 53 116 .260

Then your both wrong. He neither sucks nor is God. He's fairly average. But when you realize he's only 19, then it makes his accomplishments much more special

well yes, but it's his fault for coming up when he's 19. He's not ready is what I am trying to say. Bring him up when he is 22-24 or something.

I'd say he's more than ready. I'm sure Harper would start in almost every teams outfield.

For these, both for the MVP and this one, I voted not by who should win, but who will actually win.

That is why I chose Harper. The voters will give it to him based on his age, the hype surrounding him, and the "golden boy" mentality bestowed upon him.

As for who should win, it's most definitely Miley.