Toby Baker

From MLB Power Pros Wiki

Toby is the stuck up 2nd year player who believes himself to be the best player (pitcher). Pretty soon, you'll find out that isn't all that special (C's/D's and a top speed of only 80). He may become captain if your character doesn't. If so, he will usually reject most of your choices for new training methods, but on occasion, he will agree. If he becomes captain, Marvin will most likely become captain the third year when he leaves. A challenge or yes card will usually make him think you're too eager, and he'll "Settle" for Marvin. A No card and Marvin card obviously will prevent your captaincy. If you really want to be captain, get it after Robbie leaves. You don't ever get to play as Toby. If your captain instead of Toby in your second year, he will quit the team in a matter of months.