Power Pros Forum

Hey guys, I had a fun idea tonight where I thought I could take players from on here and make all star teams. Here's the list of players and creators. Let me know what you think.

AL All-Stars
SP Yu Darvish (Jag) Added
SP Masahiro Tanaka (Jag) Added
SP Chris Sale (Jag) Added
3B Kyle Seager (Jag)
2B Jason Kipnis (Jag)
LF Yoenis Cespedes (Jag)
3B Pablo Sandoval (Jag)
C Yan Gomes (Jag)
C/1B/3B Carlos Santana (Jag)
3B Manny Machado (Jag)
1B Chris Davis (Jag)
2B Jose Altuve (Jag)
LF/RF Nelson Cruz (Jag)
1B Eric Hosmer (Jag)
CF Mike Trout (Jag)
SP Jake Odorizzi (Mets)
3B Josh Donaldson (Jag)
C Matt Weiters (Jag)
1B Jose Abreu (Jag)
SP Sonny Gray (phillies)
SP Corey Kluber (Jag)
CL Koji Uehara (AgentP)
SP David Price (Jag)
CL Greg Holland (AgentP)
CL Dellin Betances (Jag)
SP Dallas Keuchel (Mets)
2B Brian Dozier (Jag)

NL All-Stars
SP Matt Harvey (Jag) Added
SP Jose Fernandez (Jag)
SP Julio Teheran (Jag) Added
SP Stephen Strasburg (Jag) Added
INF Kolten Wong (Mets) Added
SP Clayton Kershaw (Jag) Added
CF Marcell Ozuna (Mets) Added
3B/1B Todd Frazier (Jag)
1B/3B Pedro Alvarez (Jag)
3B/2B Matt Carpenter (Jag)
3B Nolan Arenado (Jag)
LF Corey Dickerson (Jag)
RF/LF Bryce Harper (Jag)
RF/CF Yasiel Puig (Jag)
1B Freddie Freeman (Jag)
C/1B Buster Posey (Jag)
C Jonathan Lucroy (Alloutwar)
CF Andrew McCutchen (Jag)
RF Giancarlo Stanton (Jag)
OF Carlos Gonzalez (Jag)
SP Lance Lynn (Jag)
RP Jeurys Familia (Jag)
C Wilin Rosario (Jag)
SS Andrelton Simmons (Jag)
CL Craig Kimbrel (Jag)
SS Dee Gordon (Mets)
1B Anthony Rizzo (AgentP)
OF Jon Jay (Dish)
SP Max Scherzer (Jag)
1B Paul Goldschmidt (Jag)
SS Ian Desmond (Alloutwar)
SP Doug Fister (Alloutwar)
3B/2B Anthony Rendon (Jag)
SP Madison Bumgarner (Jag)
SP Jacob deGrom (Jag)
CL Trevor Rosenthal (AnthonyP or phillies)
SP Gerrit Cole (Jag)

What do you guys think? Who would you add or drop? There are a few on here that are question marks for me, so I want some input.

I'd like to add a bunch of players (I've said this too many times) from my list. Up to you if you're willing to wait for me to finish the 24 pitchers. It would probably take me over a month to finish. maybe even more than 2

And I don't see Goldschmidt. Here's the one I made

http://www.mlbppworld.com/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=8993&start=15

Alright, I'll add Goldschmidt. And I'm willing to wait, I just wanted to get a preliminary roster and start doing the passwords.

I would cut Domonic Brown, he's not even in the majors anymore

I probably will. I just had him as a question mark.

EDIT: Just added Doug Fister and Ian Desmond. Yes or no? Brown is gone cause of outfield depth.

EDIT OF THE EDIT: Gonna start putting in a few passwords a day. Probably about four per day, that's about all the patience I have lol. Only gonna put in the ones that are definite (Kershaw, Harvey, Darvish, Trout, Stanton, etc.).

AS OF NOW, this is my idea for the starting lineups and some roster spots:

*Note, I think it'd be more fun to have the DH in use, rather than have the pitchers hit*

AL:

C Weiters / 1B Davis / 2B Altuve / 3B Donaldson / SS Machado? He was a SS wasn't he? and we don't have one at the moment / LF Cespedes / CF Trout / RF Cruz / DH Abreu

1SP Sale / 2SP Price / 3SP Tanaka / 4SP Darvish / 5SP Kluber / 6SP (if you want a 6th SP) Gray

1RP Uehara / 2RP Holland / 3RP Betances

NL:

C Posey / 1B Goldschmidt / 2B Rendon or Carpenter / 3B Rendon, Carpenter, or Arenado / SS Simmons / LF Gonzalez / CF McCutchen / RF Stanton / DH (this is a tough one) Rizzo, Puig, Harper, or Freeman

1SP Kershaw or Harvey / 2SP Kershaw or Harvey / 3SP Fernandez / 4SP Strasburg or Scherzer / 5SP Strasburg or Scherzer / 5SP Fister

1RP Familia / CL Kimbrel

Once I make more closers, then we should have a better understanding of the bullpen situation

Alright. We'll see. I kinda would like to start Harper in left, but we'll see what happens.

Tulo is better than Simmons

But he's on the game and I haven't seen a recent remake of him on here.

Oh, I see, thought this was for every active player

No, it's only for guys made on here.

Do you think deGrom could have a chance at a roster spot?

http://www.mlbppworld.com/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=9076

I second this notion.

Sure, I'll add him. The teams are starting to fill up! There's like 65 players on the list lol.