Power Pros Forum

RF/CF...... R/R

Trajectory 2
Contact 10 (11 without blues)
Power 139-144
Speed 12
Arm Strength 13-14
Fielding 9
Error Resistance 12 (should I revisit the chart I made for it? Seems like everyone is getting 11 or higher. Then again these are the better players that I've been doing)

Contact Hitter - Let's see what you guys think
Hot Hitter
Firstball Hitter - .437 BA
Good Infield Hitter
Table Setter - .324 BA in career W/out men on base
Aggressive Runner - Gets thrown out a lot from trying to stretch singles into XBH

I'd add Baserunning 2, as well, if you ask me.

I can see where you're coming from but I think that ability is associated with how fast they round the bases

My thoughts:

TRJ 2 - I can dig it
CON 10-11 (10 with contact hitter, 11 without IMO)
PWR 135 on the button (he's on my chart as a baseline )
SPD - 11 IMO. He's aggressive but not good. 12 would be too much - he maxes at 11 steals a season! Doubles are good but not that good.
ARM - his best fielding trait by far, I have 12-13. FG rates and rArm both hit 13 on the scales we've made.
FLD - so he's a net negative by some, more OK by others. I come in the 7-9 range, I'd go with 8.
E RES - I have a 7-9 here. career fldg pctg .982, league avg is .985 during that time so he's definitely under 10. I don't think you can scale this, I think you need to compare to league average to determine where someone rates.

Firstball hitter
Contact Hitter or Hot Hitter, good with either/both
I don't think table setter is warranted, with avg. just 19 pts above career norm? career OBP .386, with no one on its .395...9 pts difference.
I am ok with Gd If Hitter, sure
Aggressive runner def
Aggressive fielder??

I would agree with baserunning 2 and/or stealing 2 (if possible??). he runs into many outs...both ways, really. A steal success rate under 60% is atrocious, and FG baserunning career at -4.2...that seems to scream out as his red ability to me.
Throwing 2? accuracy seems to be an issue according to the FG scouting scores...

Star!!

I could throw Aggressive Fielding in there. Since there's another opinion towards Base Running 2, I'll add it as well. I couldn't get Star with Trout because Emily didn't want to show up.

Final:

RF/CF

Trajectory 2
Contact 10
Power 135
Speed 11
Arm Strength 13
Fielding 8
Error Resistance 8

Contact Hitter
Hot Hitter
Firstball Hitter
Good Infield Hitter
Base Running 2
Aggressive Runner
Aggressive Fielding

If I have the chance to catch the thief with low arm strength, then I'll go for Throwing 2

I'll also be giving him two blue wristbands

Couldn't get the thief to show up, so sadly he has throwing 3 still